I wrote most of this in 2020 but got stuck. I’m publishing it today, 03/17/26, with light revisions.
We live in a digital-first, always-on society and economy. We are experiencing a renaissance in productivity techniques, methodologies, and tools designed for this new digital-first era. Digital productivity emphasizes using digital tools like task managers, note-taking apps, and more to manage projects and responsibilities. Digital productivity is a sane default for the modern era of knowledge work.
Analog productivity is the art of using physical spaces and tools in the process of work, production, and creativity. It includes a wide number of tools and techniques optimized for physical interaction and space, such as:
- One-off task lists, notes, diagrams
- Notebooks, whether general-purpose or designed for a specific purpose (e.g. James Clear’s Habit Journal)
- Post-it notes
- Physical diagrams
- Sketchnotes
- Personal shorthand
- Zettelkasten
- Plan Bars
While digital productivity is a sane default for modern knowledge work, there is still a place for analog productivity – even if you’re not training in a monastery.
Even as we use digital tools for more and more kinds of work, it’s useful to maintain your ability to use physical, analog tools in your workflow. Analog tools are simple, flexible, disposable, and inexpensive.
Why Analog
Analog productivity takes advantage of our physical bodies and environments.
Physical spaces and tools are established and familiar mechanisms for our bodies and minds. Digital tools are historically new developments, whereas physical tools are more fine-tuned to our physical bodies. Analog methods have higher sensory bandwidth, by taking more advantage of aspects of our perception like peripheral vision or spatial memory.
Computers are beginning to mimic the ease of use of paper and whiteboards, but some things benefit from a visual or tactile representation that even the most modern software and hardware cannot yet replicate. Even if they approach the ease of use of physical tools, computers are unlikely to be as cheap or widely available as their analog equivalents for quite some time. It would be an unforced error to completely abandon physical tools in favor of novel tools and techniques.
Analog productivity is also a useful skillset in these turbulent times, with rapid change in world circumstances. The infrastructure that powers the Internet, computing, and human activity more generally is fragile. It is vulnerable to security penetration, geopolitical instabilities, and energy shortages, especially in the advent of near-term social collapse.
As a consequence, human knowledge work is at risk of prolonged downtime and frequent outages; at worst, we risk the permanent destruction of human knowledge. Analog productivity prepares you for the constraints imposed by intermittent connectivity, or even total “radio silence.”
Moreover, our economy and society incentivizes us to participate in the Internet as always-on
workers, consumers, and content creators. But an “extremely online” lifestyle has negative consequences for physical health, emotional well-being, and overall quality of life.
My friend David pointed out: “with digital tools, it is difficult to stem the flow of new inputs long enough to focus on developing your own insights. Knowing how to drop into ‘analog mode’ can therefore be an advantage!”
Skill in analog productivity is a useful countermeasure for external volatility. Moreover, it enables increased creativity and output while preserving our internal well-being. As my friend James Stuber pointed out, “analog is also more flexible, digital tools pigeonhole you into certain workflows.”
Analog Productivity Meta-Skills
General principles and meta-skills are far more important than any particular tool or technique.
Using analog productivity tools requires you to consciously reflect on and architect your productivity systems. What are you trying to accomplish? How do you work? What are your particular needs?
Maintaining and syncing analog productivity systems with digital systems is an evolving, important, but largely undocumented art form. You will have to decide for yourself how any analog systems you have relate to your digital systems. For example, do you want to store tasks on paper, or in a digital task manager? How will any physical notes, sketches, or diagrams that you take make their way into a digital reference application? How and when will you want to synchronize your analog systems with your digital systems?
One of the best examples that I have personally seen of this architecting and syncing is the crowdfunding video for the Analog productivity system, a physical task system designed to be used with a digital task manager. The video shows the creator browsing his digital task manager, selecting tasks for the day, and moving them onto the Analog task manager (essentially a piece of paper with a wooden stand and a few other niceties). While the components are simple, they reinforce a hybrid digital-analog workflow.
A related principle is “Get in, get out.” When you do use digital tools, hold a clear intention for what you’re trying to accomplish. Rather than being sucked in to an endless loop of consumption, sustain intention, purpose, and direction. As a reward, you’ll have increased output, energy, and sustained mental well-being.
Conclusion
Analog productivity is not obsolete. It is a valuable skill in itself, and an underrated complement to the default of digital productivity. Rather than falling into the trap of all-digital or all-analog, you can use a hybrid approach: keep digital productivity as a sane default, and use analog productivity tools and techniques when they are the right tool for the job.
Be fluent in digital and analog productivity methods, and learn to integrate the two in a way that works for you and your needs.
Thank you to David Howell, James Stuber, Christina Luo, and Jay Dugger for reviewing this blog post and for discussions about this topic.
If you enjoyed this post, give the Digital Productivity Coach a try. It's an interactive coach for digital productivity, available 24⁄7 to give you a feasible next step to improve your productivity skills.
Subscribe to my newsletter, my YouTube channel, or follow me on Twitter to get updates on my new blog posts and current projects. You can also support my work and writing on Patreon.